Failing for Success: Robert Goddard


Failing for Success: Robert Goddard

February 16, 2016

“Every vision is a joke until the first man accomplishes it; once realized, it becomes commonplace.” – Robert Goddard

By NASA (Great Images in NASA Description) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Robert Goddard knew failure and setback all too well. Goddard – the inventor who first successfully developed and fired a liquid-fueled rocket – is today widely hailed as a brilliant innovator with more than 200 patents to his name. But when he first proposed the idea of liquid-fueled rocket propulsion in space, he was widely mocked as naïve and ignorant. Even a New York Times editorial ridiculed the idea: “Professor Goddard… does not know the relation of action to reaction, and of the need to have something better than a vacuum against which to react. Of course he only seems to lack the knowledge ladled out daily in high schools.”

Harsh criticism wasn’t all Goddard had to handle. Almost every prototype rocket he flight-tested failed at one point or another due to engine or control breakdowns, a fact that he actually embraced wholeheartedly. Refusing to label bad experiments as failures, Goddard typically referred to them as “valuable negative information.”

During the late 1930s, for example, Goddard was developing very large rockets that he believed could reach high altitude. He developed an innovative engine for the rockets that cooled itself with its own excess gasoline, but he couldn’t get the design to work in practice. Though it was a practical failure, he took what he learned and developed a smaller design – the L-13 rocket – which ultimately became his highest-altitude rocket, peaking at 9,000 feet in the air.

Goddard responded to the New York Times editorial – which the publication officially redacted three days before the first moon landing, 49 years after its initial publication – with a simple and now historic quote: “Every vision is a joke until the first man accomplishes it; once realized, it becomes commonplace.” Goddard’s vision did become commonplace. Today rockets are essential components for space exploration, satellite communications, fireworks, and other aspects of modern life.

Robert Goddard is an extraordinary example of someone first considered a failure, and indeed someone who repeatedly failed and embraced it, who became an unequivocal success.


Have any suggestions for our next “Failing for Success” story? Give us a shout on TwitterFacebook, and LinkedIn. And don’t forget to subscribe to our IV Insights blog and check out our Behind the Breakthrough profiles to hear first-hand from top inventors, innovators, and more. 

More Buzz From IV

Join in the Celebration with World IP Day

With the core belief that ideas are valuable and with a commitment to ensuring a thriving market for innovation, Intellectual Ventures is proud to take part in celebrating World Intellectual Property Day.

Read More
Behind the Breakthrough Answers: What Inspires Your Work?

We asked the men and women of our Behind the Breakthrough Series – what inspires you? Hear from two interviewees from IV’s Global Good division on how they approach some of the world’s most significant challenges.

Read More
Failing for Success: Alexander Graham Bell

March marks the quick succession of two important anniversaries in the life of Alexander Graham Bell and though we think of his invention as one that changed the course of history, success for Bell wasn’t always smooth.

Read More